Highgate Partners Winter Update

Highgate Partners Winter Update
Text Link

Q2 2023 Economic commentary

As the grey clouds gather for winter, it's pleasing to report the sun is still shining on portfolios.

Global share markets advanced again during the quarter, with the gains being led by developed markets and, most notably, large US technology companies.

With moderating US inflation and signs that the American economy had displayed resilience in spite of higher interest rates, global investor sentiment remained generally positive.

There was some caution surrounding the US debt ceiling negotiations reported at the beginning of the quarter, however, in early June, Congress approved legislation that suspended the debt ceiling in a deal that was expected to have very little impact on economic growth.

The Chinese share market bucked the generally positive trend as the economic rebound following their post-Covid reopening, quickly began to cool.

After declining over the first quarter, global interest rates were generally on the rise again with most major central banks continuing to raise rates over the quarter. However, in a positive move signifying that inflation (at least in the US) may now be in retreat, the US Federal Reserve was the first central bank to pause their rate hiking program in June.


AI – the rise of the machines

It’s remarkable to note that the returns from only seven companies (Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Amazon, Meta Platforms, Alphabet and Tesla) account for almost three-quarters of the total US share market return so far this year.

The first six on this list are technology companies which have benefited from the growing hype and excitement surrounding artificial intelligence (AI) - specifically natural language processing tools such as ChatGPT.

Despite stubborn inflation and rising interest rates that typically hamper the performance of growth focused technology companies, the prices of AI-linked businesses that might benefit from the future implementation of this technology have been driven significantly higher.

The question for this technology is – where to from here?

Wall Street and the news media in general have been quick to promote the hype around AI technology, with some labelling it the start of a fourth industrial revolution that will help transform life on earth. Others say the sudden enthusiasm for AI has the same hallmarks as the meteoric rise of cryptocurrencies and meme stocks during the Covid pandemic, or the mania surrounding the internet companies of the dotcom era during the early 2000s.

The challenge for investors is that even if AI is to become a utility in our daily lives, it doesn’t mean every AI company is automatically worth buying, especially at their current (much higher) valuations.

In that regard, the dotcom bubble may hold valuable lessons. Hype about the internet drove up the technology-heavy Nasdaq Composite index by 400% between 1995 and 2000. When the dotcom bubble finally burst, the Nasdaq subsequently fell nearly 77% between March 2000 and October 2002, with many of the once high-flying internet companies falling all the way to zero.

Looking back, excitement about the long term benefits of the internet was well founded, but that didn’t stop investors eventually losing a lot of money chasing the hype.


Recessions– do they matter?

In New Zealand, the economy is currently wrestling with rising interest rates, a cost of living crisis and a general shortage of skilled workers. We are also, based on recent growth data, in a technical recession. What’s not quite so clear, is whether we should be concerned about it.

A recession is defined as two consecutive quarters of contraction in economic activity, or in simple terms, it’s what happens when the economy shrinks. Economic output (measured by changes in gross domestic product (GDP)) tends to shrink during a recession because there's generally higher unemployment, less consumer demand and reduced production of goods and services. Housing prices are also prone to weakening during recessions.

Although New Zealand’s economic output has declined (partly due to the destructive effects of cyclone Gabrielle) and our housing market is currently weaker, unemployment has been surprisingly slow to rise and consumer spending continues to hold up remarkably well.

It’s that combination of factors (some weaker, but some still strong) that currently make this recession a little less concerning. Yes, it’s a small mathematical decline, but it’s not a meaningful contraction across a broader range of categories where employment, consumer spending, retail sales and production are all struggling. That would be more concerning.

In general, recessions can last anywhere from a few months to a several years, but over the past several decades most recessions in New Zealand have been less than a year. On that basis, we may already be closer to the end of this recession than the beginning. Unless conditions were to suddenly take a significant turn for the worse, the fact that we may be in a technical recession today shouldn’t, on its own, be terribly concerning.


Investing during a recession

Although economic activity shrinks during a recession it doesn’t mean investment returns will also shrink. While recessions can certainly lead to weaker markets, when we look at the average performance of share markets during recessions the findings are interesting.

For example, the main share market index in the US (the S&P 500) has actually increased by an average of around 1% during all recession periods since 1945. In part, that’s because share markets usually peak before the start of a recession and bottom out before their conclusion. In other words, the worst is generally over for shares before it’s over for the rest of the economy.

It’s also why share markets are widely acknowledged as being forward-looking. When a share market is declining it can (amongst other things) be a sign that investors might believe the economy could be headed towards recession.

If an economy eventually moves into recession, share prices are typically already lower by that time. However, when share prices are lower the expected future return from owning shares generally increases, making share ownership more attractive! And, given the average short duration of most recessions, it’s not unreasonable for the confirmation of a recession to be viewed as a long term buy signal.

To reinforce the point that a recession doesn’t guarantee a poor investment outcome, we only have to look at the performance of our own share market over the period from September 2022 to end March 2023, when the New Zealand economy is now acknowledged to have been in a technical recession. The local S&P/NZX 50 Index (gross with imputation) went up 3.79% between September and December 2022, followed by a further increase of 3.89% between January and March 2023.

These returns are welcome in any economic environment.


Interest rates – what next?

We need to continue taking our cues from the Reserve Bank, because they are responsible for setting the level of short term interest rates in New Zealand. These short term rates are set when they adjust the official cash rate (OCR). Longer term interest rates, including mortgage rates, are determined by market forces, but all are related in some way to the prevailing level of the OCR.

In November 2022, the Reserve Bank projected a peak in the OCR of 5.50% and, after another 0.25% increase at their May 2023 meeting, that is where the OCR now sits – at exactly 5.50%. The wider market is not yet convinced this will be the end of New Zealand’s rate rising cycle, but through the quarter the market consensus was that the Reserve Bank will pause at this level, at least for a while. By pausing here, it will allow time for the lagged effects of the previous rate rises to continue to gradually slow the economy down and bring inflation back towards their long term target band of 1-3%.

Having moved the OCR up quickly since October 2021, and with New Zealand already in a technical recession, the Reserve Bank will tread very lightly now. While they are intent on dampening inflation, they don’t want to risk turning a mild recession into a deeper and more prolonged downturn. They also know that with over 50% of outstanding mortgages due to be refixed at higher interest rates over the coming year, this will act as a further handbrake on discretionary consumer spending over the coming months.

On the positive side, there is enough early evidence to suggest that monetary policy is beginning to work. Economic growth is already contracting. Inflation, on a quarterly basis, is slowly dropping and taking inflation expectations with it. And the labour market has moved from being extremely tight to now showing a very slight increase in the unemployment rate.

If these trends continue, there is plenty of scope for short-term interest rates to begin falling again in New Zealand in 2024.


Stay focused

Following the significant Covid interruptions of early 2020, central banks around the world are still trying to navigate the best route to take for their economies to achieve greater stability and prosperity.

It hasn’t been straight-forward. The economic reboot from a near global shutdown has thrown up a myriad of unexpected challenges – supply chain issues, production shortages, cost pressures, labour shortages, galloping inflation and, recently, rapidly rising global interest rates.

However, one by one, these challenges are being met.

That economic growth has come under pressure in the meantime is entirely understandable. That policy makers will eventually win this battle, is equally inevitable.

As individual investors, we simply need to keep our focus on the things we can control – following our strategic plan, staying diversified and maintaining discipline.

Challenges, fads, speculation and uncertainty will always be a part of why markets will deliver positive long term returns. It’s the reward paid to investors for taking investment risk.

And the best way to manage those risks is to acknowledge their existence, develop strategies to manage or mitigate them, and then relentlessly implement those strategies –something all good advisers are ideally placed to help with.


Key market movements for the quarter

Central banks maintained their laser-like focus on combatting inflation by continuing to raise interest rates globally during the quarter.

With the Eurozone and New Zealand economies already in a mild recession and other regions facing a lower growth outlook, at least in the near term, share markets were not burdened by high expectations.

However, with plenty of bad news having already been factored into share prices last year, it was pleasing to see international developed share markets still perform strongly over the quarter. Leading the way were a number of mega-cap US technology firms identified as potential beneficiaries of any greater movement towards increased utilisation of artificial intelligence.

Although share market returns across Australasia and the emerging markets were less significant, these regions also contributed positively to investor returns during the quarter.

With global interest rates moving higher again, in particular in the UK and Australia where inflation pressures were proving a little harder to dampen, the overall returns from global bonds were fairly flat.

When the US Federal Reserve announced they were pausing their interest rate hiking programme in June, it provided a tangible and important sign, to end the quarter, that the global fight against inflation was making positive progress.

International shares

+7.5% (hedged to NZD)
+9.0% (unhedged)

US and Eurozone share markets made good gains in the second quarter, with the bulk of these gains coming in June.

Information technology companies benefitted from investor excitement about the future applications for artificial intelligence and a number of technology and semi-conductor companies saw their prices appreciate strongly.

Although both regions raised interest rates during the quarter, the greater resilience of the US economy encouraged the Federal Reserve to pause their hiking programme in June - an encouraging sign for equity markets.

The UK share market was weaker over the quarter. Higher than expected core inflation data resulting from strong job and wage growth figures suggested the Bank of England still had work to do to get on top of inflation on a sustainable basis. This led to a reacceleration in interest rate hikes for the UK which presented a clear headwind for the domestic UK share market.

Against major currencies, the New Zealand dollar was a little weaker through the quarter which meant increased reported returns for investors holding unhedged foreign assets.

The MSCI World ex-Australia Index delivered a healthy return of +7.5% for the quarterhedged to the NZ dollar, and +9.0% for the unhedged index.

Source: MSCI World ex-Australia Index (net div.)

Emerging markets shares


Emerging markets posted a small positive return over the second quarter, rising +1.0% in US dollar terms.

The Chinese share market was a major contributor to the lower returns. The anticipated economic rebound following China’s reopening after the Covid-19 crisis began to falter, driving Chinese shares sharply lower.

Hungary, Poland and Greece were the top performing emerging markets in USD terms despite rising recessionary fears in Europe. Brazil was also a top performer as growing optimism about potential interest rate cuts and better than expected first quarter growth figures, led to strong gains in Brazil’s Bovespa Index.

Indian shares also performed well, driven by foreign inflows and steady earnings, as encouraging economic data boosted sentiment towards the country.

In spite of China’s weakness, the emerging markets group contributed positively, and the slightly weaker New Zealand dollar over the quarter meant the MSCI Emerging Markets Index produced a quarterly return of +2.9% in unhedged New Zealand dollar terms.

Source: MSCI Emerging Markets Index (gross div.)


New Zealand shares


The New Zealand share market, as measured by the S&P/NZX 50 Index, eked out a small positive return in the second quarter of 2023.

Of the top50 companies, four in particular stood out. Software company Serko Ltd reaffirmed its strong growth projections for next year and soared +56.9% over the quarter. Retirement village operators Arvida Group and Ryman Healthcare gained +38.0% and +25.3% respectively, with Arvida announcing a record profit this year and Ryman projecting a lift in net profits of 20-30% next year. Fletcher Building rounded out the notable performers, advancing +24.3% on the back of improved overall news flow.

It wasn’t such a memorable quarter for all New Zealand companies, however. Pharmaceutical supplier Ebos Group saw its share price slump -21.0% following news that the Chemist Warehouse would not be renewing a $1.9 billion supply contract when it expires next June. While a2 Milk shares drifted -14.3% following further weakness in Chinese infant formula demand.

Source: S&P/NZX 50 Index (gross with imputation credits)


Australian shares


The Australian share market (S&P/ASX 200Total Return Index) registered a small gain in the second quarter, advancing+1.0% in Australian dollar terms.

Although numerous micro-cap basic materials firms and technology companies posted stellar gains during the quarter, these had an egligible impact on the performance of the market which is much more heavily influenced by the results of the big banking companies and the mega-cap basic materials firms, BHP and Rio Tinto.

With BHP and Rio Tinto down -4.7% and -4.5% respectively, on the back of ongoing weakness in iron ore and industrial metals prices, this was a major factor in the subdued performance of the index.

The major banks performed a little better on average, as two further increases in the Australian cash rate during the quarter were seen as a positive for bank lending margins and profitability. ANZ Group led the banking cohort gaining +6.9%, with the Commonwealth Bank (+2.0%) and Westpac (+1.8%), also recording gains.

While the local Australian index only recorded a small gain, the slightly weaker New Zealand dollar meant that reported returns to unhedged New Zealand investors improved to +2.6% over the quarter.

Source: S&P/ASX 200 Index (total return)


International fixed interest


The second quarter of 2023 saw a significant drop in bond market volatility.

Government bond yields were generally on the rise again, although there was some divergence. UK and Australian bonds both underperformed their peers due to reporting higher-than-expected inflation figures and a renewed resolve by these central banks to combat inflation.

With the exception of the Bank of Japan, all major central banks kept raising interest rates over the quarter. However, the US Federal Reserve was the first to pause in June, leaving short term US interest rates at 5%-5.25% after more than a year of consecutive rate increases.

With US growth surprising to the upside, and with a ‘soft landing’ scenario now being the market consensus, US corporate bonds outperformed US government bonds.

Over the quarter, the US 10 year bond yield increased from 3.47% to 3.84%, with the two year bond yield moving from 4.04%to 4.90%, marking a further inversion of the US yield curve. Germany’s 10 year bond yield rose more sedately from 2.30% to 2.39%, while the UK 10 year yield jumped from 3.49% to 4.39% on the back of disappointing inflation figures.

The FTSE World Government Bond Index 1-5 Years (hedged to NZD) returned -0.2% for the quarter, while the broader Bloomberg Global Aggregate Bond Index (hedged to NZD) gained +0.1%.

Source: FTSE World Government Bond Index 1-5Years (hedged to NZD)


New Zealand fixed interest


Consistent with overseas trends, on 24 May the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) raised the Official Cash Rate (OCR) by a further 0.25% to a level of 5.50%.

In the accompanying monetary policy statement, the RBNZ noted that “inflation is expected to continue to decline from its peak and with it measures of inflation expectations. However, core inflation pressures will remain until capacity constraints ease further. While employment is above its maximum sustainable level, there are now signs of labour shortages easing and vacancies declining.”

New Zealand government bond yields rose during the quarter, with the New Zealand 10 year bond yield increasing from 4.23% to 4.65% by 30 June. With better-than-expected economic and company news helping ease investor concerns, New Zealand corporate bonds outperformed government bonds over the period.

The S&P/NZX A-Grade Corporate Bond Index rose +0.4% for the quarter, while the longer duration but higher quality S&P/NZX NZ Government Bond Index fell-1.6%.

Source: S&P/NZX A-Grade Corporate Bond Index



Table 1: Asset class returns to 30 June 2023



Don’t fall for the rise in disinformation and scams

Financial disinformation

The pandemic showed the power of a previously unknown virus to spread through the global population, threating health and creating economic mayhem. But few people appreciate the power of bad information to go viral in a similar way, endangering their wealth.

Globally, regulators are warning of an increase in financial disinformation and outright scams, fuelled by the growth of social media use, the failure of a traditional media gatekeepers, rising isolation during the pandemic and the human propensity to fall for get-rich-quick pitches.

The result of all this is people are losing billions of dollars annually by acting on unreliable information, often spread by bad actors through digital media channels.

So just as we learned during the pandemic about maintaining good hygiene and consulting health professionals, the explosion of financial disinformation highlights the importance of sticking to sound investment principles and having a trusted financial advisor onside.

The growth of scams

Just about every week, a financial regulator somewhere is alerting people to this issue. Unfortunately, the perpetrators are becoming increasingly sophisticated.

In New Zealand, the Financial Markets Authority says about 20% of the population has been targeted by investment scams. Among the latest, a New Zealand man lost his life savings after agreeing to sell his house and using the proceeds to invest in a fake AAA-rated term deposit supposedly paying 13.5% per annum.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) says losses to bond investment scams nearly tripled in the first half of 2022. Consumers lost more than $20 million to imposters impersonating banks and claiming to offer legitimate government bonds or term deposits.

Overall, scams robbed Australians of a record $3.1 billion in 2022, the ACCC says, with investment information scams the highest loss category.

Confirming that this is a global phenomenon, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently charged 11 individuals in a fraudulent cryptocurrency pyramid and Ponzi scheme that raised more than $300 million from thousands of retail investors worldwide.

Regulators in the UK have also noted a significant rise in scammers taking advantage of the growing use of digital communication tools. Specifically, the UK Financial Conduct Authority found perpetrators are using screen-sharing software to take control of victims’ computers, steal their passwords and drain their bank accounts.

These rogue operators have become so sophisticated that in some cases, when investors seek to retrieve their money, the scammers impersonate recovery agents who offer the victims help in getting their money back, in exchange for a fee of course.

The rise of social media

Outright fraud is not the only information threat to investors. The demise of the gatekeeping role of traditional media and the rise of unverified and unedited social media content can encourage people into unwise short-term trading, often based on unreliable rumours and opinions.

The meme stock boom of 2021 took off during the pandemic, as people stuck at home started trading popular shares using cheap or free trading apps and sharing information on social media channels.

Social media has also created a new type of financial celebrity known popularly as the ‘finfluencer’. These are people, often without qualifications, who offer advice on anything from buying a house, to setting up a budget to building a global share portfolio.

Regulators have started to issue warnings (or guidance) to social media influencers, reminding them that, like any licensed financial adviser, they are still subject to the laws related to discussing financial products and services.

Social media in itself is not entirely a malign phenomenon. In many ways, it democratises access to information. But it also carries risks for users who unwittingly assume that all the information they find there can be trusted and reliably acted upon.

Again, this highlights the value that a trusted financial adviser brings, in both acting as an information filter and understanding the needs and goals of each individual client.

Tips to improve your information hygiene

All of this means that exercising information hygiene habits to protect our wealth is as important as the lessons we adopted during the pandemic to protect our health. These healthy information habits include the following:

·        If an investment opportunity sounds too good to be true, you should exercise scepticism. Offers of ‘high return-low risk’ should set off alarm bells.

·        Be wary of any unsolicited offer or unexpected contact, particularly if it comes via a social media platform.

·        Tighten up your privacy controls on social media and protect yourself from identity theft. Do not share your screen with someone you have never met.

·        Use trusted, established sources for financial information as much as possible.

·        Limit your media consumption. Just because you can check news headlines and your portfolio 24 hours a day doesn’t mean that you should.

·        Most importantly, work with a licensed financial adviser who understands your needs, circumstances, goals and risk appetite.

This article has been adapted from an article titled Information Hygiene, written by Jim Parker of Dimensional Fund Advisors.


Recent Articles

Need professional financial advice?

Get in touch with us to arrange a free, no obligation initial consultation
Schedule A Meeting